[DM-MUG] Register's piece on laptops in DM Schools.... and others?

[Tony LaFemina]

edkelly14@mchsi.com wrote:

> <snip>
>
> As a former elected school board member in one of the largest (by 
> area) school districts in the state, I am interested in getting kids a 
> great education.  We all have to care about our kids and their 
> education.  But I think anyone promoting universal use of computers 
> should read the book' Silicone Snake Oil.
>
> Though at first glance it sounds great, the well meaning proposal 
> suffers on several counts:  Students need real basics like literacy 
> and math skills first, and promotion of expensive items like these can 
> take money away from more vital education needs -- like teachers and 
> books.
>
> <snip>
>
> But you still have to read to use a laptop, or to read a computer 
> instruction manual....  Basic literacy will not be enhanced by giving 
> away free computers at a cost of laying off teachers or cutting back 
> on books.
>
>
>
> Ed Kelly
> edkelly14@mchsi.com
> also usdoj@mac.com
> and ekelly7@sc.rr.com
> and edkelly@netins.net
>
>
>
Hi All

I think Ed has a point. Better yet! Ed DOES HAVE a point! For all of you 
that remember when technology introduced the calculator. There was a 
brief period where the educational powers-that-be just about made it 
mandatory for each student to have one available during tests. I've seen 
the results of that farce. It's really sad when you come face-to-face 
with someone who don't have the sense to use their fingers and toes for 
simple addition.

Like Ed says, learn the basics first. Then introduce the 
latest-and-greatest technology has to offer. Only then will kids have a 
fighting chance.



-- 
Tony LaFemina
When you want to do more than just buy software
http://hometown.aol.com/visitmacland/index.html
mailto:remacs@optonline.net