[Cialug] MSFT to partner with Novell

[Josh More]

 So far as MS releasing WM codecs as OSS, I agree.  That will not
happen.

However, what may well happen is that the MS partnership will Novell
will allow the w32codecs package to work better.  Then, the
indemnification
portion with allow SUSE and noncommercial distros like Ubuntu to
include
these codecs legally.


 

-- 
-Josh More, RHCE, CISSP, NCLP 
 morej at alliancetechnologies.net 
 515-245-7701


>>> David Champion <dchampion at visionary.com> 11/06/06 10:30 AM >>> 
Josh More wrote:

> 2) MS agrees not to "assert its patents" against noncommercial open
> source developers or developers whose code is accepted into the
>     commercial SUSE* line.
>     My opinon: MS has been less legalistic as of late, so this
doesn't
> really cost them much.  Novell (commercial) and the Debian/Ubuntu 
>     (noncommercial) line are clear winners here.  Red Hat, however,
> does not seem to be covered.  Further, this *could* be the start of
>     a patent- centralization effort, which would be good.
>     Unknowns:  MS has licensed a lot of patents, and it is unlikely
> that this agreement covers those.  We will likely see some
squabbling
>     over this before everything clarifies.  If it stabilizes
properly,
> we might be able to see free (as in speech and beer) and legal
support
> for
>     Windows multimedia formats.  This would be a very good thing.

I don't see how this is really any different than the SCO tactic of 
saying they wouldn't sue you if you were a SCO customer.

Regardless of any deal with Novell, MS doesn't "own" linux, and any 
preferential legal treatment of Suse users over RedHat and other 
commercial Linux customers is bunk. One example is the MS patent on 
automatic updates. Every Linux vendor has a version of this, and MS has

made noises in the past of invoking legal action on them, because they

patented it (well after it already existed in other forms).

It really doesn't gain them anything legally, it is simply a scare 
tactic to get people to spend money with them or their partners.

MS isn't going to release Windows Media codecs as OSS. They wouldn't be

able to enforce DRM.

- dc


_______________________________________________
Cialug mailing list
Cialug at cialug.org
http://cialug.org/mailman/listinfo/cialug